Things That Can Go Wrong After Selling Your Home

things that go wrong when selling
Photo: © Big Stock Photo

When a buyer makes an offer on my listing, the first thought that crosses my mind is how to be proactive. How to prevent the many things that can go wrong after selling a home. My sellers, on the other hand, are ecstatic and happy to have received an offer. They aren't pondering possible catastrophes. They are focused on closing, and might even be wondering why they needed an agent in the first place since all of this appeared so danged simple to do.

They are not thinking about the upfront work that went into preparing a home for sale. From pricing the home correctly to the home staging, photography, strategic marketing, broker tours, open houses, online promotions. Nope, what they see is an agent stuck a for sale sign in the yard and now their home is sold. End of story, in their book.

Accepting a purchase offer is only partway to a conclusion. Think of home selling as a big pie divided into four sections: 1/4 up-front preparation, offer negotiations as 1/4, getting through the home inspections as another 1/4 and finally navigating the final loan requirements as the last step. 

A lot can go wrong after the home goes into contract. This is when your choice of a listing agent becomes evident. Did you hire an inexperienced agent who may handle those final stages poorly or a discount agent who might not offer mid-escrow nor closing services at all?

No earnest money deposit.

Our Sacramento MLS demands we change the status of our listings within 3 days, and many other multiple listing services require a similar time frame. Not to mention, buyer's agents are very angry if they have lined up a potential showing, only to discover the home is already sold but the listing agent did not change the status in MLS. Sellers are also anxious to stop the showings and start the packing.

The first thing that can go wrong when selling your home is to discover the buyer has not deposited funds into escrow, there is no earnest money deposit on file. Since earnest money is generally a contractual obligation and it shows the buyer's good faith, it makes everybody uncomfortable and it's a big red flag if the money is not deposited.

The bigger problem is having changed the status in MLS to pending and because the buyer canceled due to cold feet, now the home must go back on the market as a back on market home.

A bad home inspection.

To be fair, it is not always a bad home inspection that freaks out some buyers as many buyers know little about inspections and cannot properly interpret them. Often, their agents are of no assistance, either. If they were unlucky enough to have hired a bad home inspector, they also can't trust the inspector. Guys can call themselves a home inspector without any training nor licensing in some states such as California, for example.

Plenty of buyers want to cancel after a home inspection, and they don't realize all homes have defects, or they ask the seller to repair issues or demand outrageous sums of money for minor repairs. We recently had a buyer demand in a Request for Repair that my seller fixes a tiny hole in a wall inside a closet and oil a squeaky door, on top of which the seller was selling AS IS and lived out of state. We denied the request and it still closed. Many transactions, though, fall apart after a home inspection.

A low appraisal.

You'll meet agents who will insist on handing comparable sales to an appraiser, and that's so insulting to the appraiser. They don't stop to consider that an appraiser frowns on that type of practice. That's like telling an appraiser he or she doesn't know how to do the job. Agents think they are being proactive and helpful and instead, they appear like a know-it-all.

Some agents will hear that other agents do hand comps to the appraiser as a matter of practice. Due to the insecurity that so many agents possess, they always think other agents know something they do not. In this case, they would be wrong.

You do need an agent who knows how to communicate with an appraiser and can help the appraiser to evaluate the home differently if the value is difficult to determine. This is an area where your agent definitely can break or make the transaction for you, and where experience often pays off. You're not out of the woods until the appraiser signs off the appraisal and the value is at your sales price.

Underwriting rejects the file.

Perhaps the mortgage loan officer who initially pre-approved the buyer did not gather all of the facts. Maybe the buyer is divorcing and the soon to be ex-spouse refuses to sign a quitclaim deed. Maybe the buyer's employment income was dependent on bonuses that can't be substantiated. Perhaps the buyer's ex-husband has a short sale on his record within the past few years, or there is a judgment filed against one of the borrowers. Underwriting is the jackpot of mistakes because so many things can go wrong in underwriting.

Buyer possession.

Sure, your purchase contract probably defines the date of buyer possession but it doesn't do any good if the seller can't move out or the buyer suddenly needs to move sooner, both of which can happen. Coordinating the move out date, scheduling the final walk-through and making sure there are no surprises, all repairs have been completed as agreed and the home has been cleaned by the seller is not always simple.

It's important to remember we need flexibility and calm nerves, both of which are often in short supply the closer it gets to closing. Sometimes the best course of action is to extend the closing or arrange a seller rentback.


At the time of writing, Elizabeth Weintraub, License #00697006, is a Broker-Associate at Lyon Real Estate in Sacramento, California.

Was this page helpful?
The Balance uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
  1. Sacramento Realtor. "Summary of Changes to MetroList Rules," Page 15.

  2. Inspection Certification Associates. "California Home Inspection Licensing."

Related Articles